Best Places in New York, United States to Invest in Airbnbs, Short-Term Rentals in 2025

Last updated: January 31, 2025

Discover the most lucrative short-term rental markets in New York, United States with AirROI's comprehensive investment guide. Whether you’re an experienced property investor or just starting your Airbnb journey, through detailed analysis of key metrics across premier global, our data-driven insights reveal where smart money is flowing in the short-term rental space. Using advanced market analytics and real performance data, we’ve identified investment hotspots that combine strong rental demand, favorable regulations, and optimal revenue potential.

Read on to explore the top-performing short-term rental markets that should be on every investor’s radar in 2024.

Top Short-Term Rental Cities in New York, United States

Rank:#1Market:New YorkCountry:United StatesProperties:12,552Monthly Revenue:$1899.43Daily Rate:$198.96Occupancy:44.34%Regulation:Moderate
Rank:#2Market:Town of East HamptonCountry:United StatesProperties:1,437Monthly Revenue:$6200.72Daily Rate:$979.48Occupancy:37.04%Regulation:Low
Rank:#3Market:Town of SouthamptonCountry:United StatesProperties:1,323Monthly Revenue:$6084.62Daily Rate:$961.78Occupancy:35.78%Regulation:Low
Rank:#4Market:BuffaloCountry:United StatesProperties:822Monthly Revenue:$2300.95Daily Rate:$165.22Occupancy:49.10%Regulation:Low
Rank:#5Market:City of Saratoga SpringsCountry:United StatesProperties:816Monthly Revenue:$3986.55Daily Rate:$562.40Occupancy:38.02%Regulation:Low
Rank:#6Market:City of RochesterCountry:United StatesProperties:728Monthly Revenue:$1674.02Daily Rate:$126.76Occupancy:48.02%Regulation:Low
Rank:#7Market:Town of BrookhavenCountry:United StatesProperties:690Monthly Revenue:$3885.92Daily Rate:$533.10Occupancy:42.37%Regulation:Low
Rank:#8Market:Town of SoutholdCountry:United StatesProperties:483Monthly Revenue:$4799.45Daily Rate:$615.30Occupancy:36.84%Regulation:Low
Rank:#9Market:Town of HunterCountry:United StatesProperties:466Monthly Revenue:$3490.00Daily Rate:$379.63Occupancy:33.70%Regulation:Low
Rank:#10Market:Town of SaugertiesCountry:United StatesProperties:411Monthly Revenue:$4489.65Daily Rate:$350.19Occupancy:44.96%Regulation:Low
Rank:#11Market:Village of Lake PlacidCountry:United StatesProperties:409Monthly Revenue:$3932.79Daily Rate:$400.27Occupancy:37.94%Regulation:Low
Rank:#12Market:City of Niagara FallsCountry:United StatesProperties:403Monthly Revenue:$2478.77Daily Rate:$200.54Occupancy:44.71%Regulation:Low
Rank:#13Market:City of SyracuseCountry:United StatesProperties:385Monthly Revenue:$1724.27Daily Rate:$135.49Occupancy:47.97%Regulation:Low
Rank:#14Market:Town of Lake GeorgeCountry:United StatesProperties:348Monthly Revenue:$2835.60Daily Rate:$337.44Occupancy:36.56%Regulation:Low
Rank:#15Market:Town of ShandakenCountry:United StatesProperties:341Monthly Revenue:$2669.08Daily Rate:$285.51Occupancy:34.73%Regulation:Low
Rank:#16Market:Town of WindhamCountry:United StatesProperties:319Monthly Revenue:$3346.63Daily Rate:$434.32Occupancy:30.75%Regulation:Low
Rank:#17Market:City of AlbanyCountry:United StatesProperties:312Monthly Revenue:$1629.65Daily Rate:$125.64Occupancy:47.32%Regulation:Low
Rank:#18Market:City of IthacaCountry:United StatesProperties:289Monthly Revenue:$3036.15Daily Rate:$243.45Occupancy:51.52%Regulation:Low
Rank:#19Market:Town of WoodstockCountry:United StatesProperties:275Monthly Revenue:$3220.94Daily Rate:$335.01Occupancy:39.18%Regulation:Moderate
Rank:#20Market:Town of IslipCountry:United StatesProperties:252Monthly Revenue:$3271.76Daily Rate:$426.36Occupancy:46.07%Regulation:Low
Rank:#21Market:Town of JohnsburgCountry:United StatesProperties:252Monthly Revenue:$2515.50Daily Rate:$330.01Occupancy:30.81%Regulation:Low
Rank:#22Market:Town of North ElbaCountry:United StatesProperties:252Monthly Revenue:$3601.21Daily Rate:$396.10Occupancy:40.35%Regulation:Low
Rank:#23Market:City of YonkersCountry:United StatesProperties:229Monthly Revenue:$2349.67Daily Rate:$153.77Occupancy:54.32%Regulation:Low
Rank:#24Market:Town of CatskillCountry:United StatesProperties:219Monthly Revenue:$3635.92Daily Rate:$292.27Occupancy:42.64%Regulation:Low
Rank:#25Market:Town of EllicottvilleCountry:United StatesProperties:210Monthly Revenue:$3634.93Daily Rate:$375.94Occupancy:35.47%Regulation:Low
Rank:#26Market:Town of MiddletownCountry:United StatesProperties:207Monthly Revenue:$3083.12Daily Rate:$278.94Occupancy:38.35%Regulation:Low
Rank:#27Market:Town of WebbCountry:United StatesProperties:207Monthly Revenue:$3004.01Daily Rate:$341.55Occupancy:37.66%Regulation:Low
Rank:#28Market:Town of JayCountry:United StatesProperties:202Monthly Revenue:$3742.95Daily Rate:$269.37Occupancy:47.19%Regulation:Low
Rank:#29Market:Town of HectorCountry:United StatesProperties:200Monthly Revenue:$3700.68Daily Rate:$301.05Occupancy:47.62%Regulation:Low
Rank:#30Market:City of HudsonCountry:United StatesProperties:196Monthly Revenue:$3383.08Daily Rate:$269.58Occupancy:44.20%Regulation:Low

Our Methodology

At AirROI, we leverage advanced technology to process and analyze the world’s most comprehensive short-term rental dataset, helping investors make data-driven decisions.

Data Collection

  • Real-time data aggregation from tens of millions of listings globally
  • Comprehensive tracking of market-specific performance metrics
  • Local regulatory tracking

Data Processing

  • AI-powered analysis of booking patterns
  • Advanced machine learning for trend identification
  • Forward-looking market forecasting
  • Cross-market performance benchmarking

Key Metrics We Track

  • Occupancy rates and seasonal patterns
  • Revenue performance (ADR, RevPAR)
  • Market demand indicators
  • Investment metrics (ROI, operating costs)
  • Regulatory compliance requirements

How is your STR performing?

Your vacation rental may be amazing, but is it better than your competition? Enjoy the best-in-class AI-powered analytics for free!

Discover Insights